The Struggle for the Soul of Islam: Inclusive and Exclusive Tendencies Since September 11
Professor Michael Sells
Haverford College
śŮ˛šłŮąđ:ĚýMarch 13, 2002
Event Recap
Michael Sells, a noted scholar of Islam and Professor of Religion at Haverford College, asserted in March 13 lecture at Boston College that what the Taliban and other conservative Islamic movements are really fighting is a war against the TV set, and what it represents: a culture of global advertisement and the idolatry of images. It was no accident, he argued, that the September 11 attacks were âchoreographedâ to ensure that the second plane crashing into the World Trade Center would be captured on TV; this was all part of Osama bin Ladenâs plan to defeat the United States by what he believed was Americansâ enslavement to images.
Sells sought to convey a sense of the ideology motivating radical Islamic groups, and to contrast these movements with the much broader Islamic cultural tradition that is often hidden behind its politicized face. While some interpret the actions of groups like the Taliban, and the attacks of September11, as a vindication of the âclash of civilizationsâ theory, Sells argues that the theory offers too limited a view, because it fails to recognize that elements of Islamic culture have something to contribute to the West.
In identifying three things that are ârightâ in Islamâits sense of time, its poetry, and the QurâanâSells sought a way to âtranslateâ these elements for his Western audience. The Islamic sense of time, for example, grows out of the experience of a lunar calendar with no fixed dates, and a daily system of five calls to prayer based on natural observations and an orientation to Mecca. In addition to its implications for the development of Muslim astronomy and mathematics, this system has helped to create a ânon-transactionalâ experience of time in Islamic society; people are less concerned about getting where they need to go and more interested in developing relationships along the way. Sells notes that this notion of time is ânot terribly efficient,â but might have something to teach us nonetheless. In a similar way, Americans could benefit by learning more about how traditions of shared poetry and the aural experience of the Qurâan have contributed to a rich culture. In sum, the present crisis demands what Sells calls an âapophaticâ politics, one that resists fixed cultural categories and strives for an inclusive, non-oppositional perspective.
About the Speaker
Michael Sells, a noted scholar of Islam and Professor of Religion at Haverford College, asserted in a March 13 lecture at Boston College that what the Taliban and other conservative Islamic movements are really fighting is a war against the television set, and what it represents: a culture of global advertisement and the idolatry of images. It was no accident, he argued, that the September 11 attacks were âchoreographedâ to ensure that the second plane crashing into the World Trade Center would be captured on television. This was part of Osama bin Ladenâs plan to defeat the United States by what he believed was Americansâ enslavement to images.
Sells sought to convey a sense of the ideology motivating radical Islamic groups, and to contrast these movements with the much broader Islamic cultural tradition that is often hidden behind its politicized face. While some interpret the actions of groups like the Taliban, and the attacks of September 11, as a vindication of the âclash of civilizationsâ theory, Sells argues that the theory offers too limited a view, because it fails to recognize that elements of Islamic culture have something to contribute to the West.